Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Kitzinger v. Geo. V. Clark Co.

January 19, 1945

KITZINGER
v.
GEO. V. CLARK CO., INC.



Author: Hand

Before L. HAND, AUGUSTUS N. HAND and FRANK, Circuit Judges.

AUGUSTUS N. HAND, Circuit Judge.

The question raised by this appeal is whether the referee in bankruptcy erred in denying a discharge to the bankrupt Stanley Kitzinger on the ground that the latter had obtained credit from the objecting creditor Geo. V. Clark Co., Inc., by making a materially false statement in writing respecting the bankrupt's financial condition, and whether the District Court erred in affirming the decision of the referee. We think that the financial statement was not false and that the bankrupt is entitled to a discharge.

Kitzinger was the president and a substantial stockholder of Golden Bear Cookie Co., Inc., to which the objecting creditor Geo. V. Clark Co., Inc., had sold containers for its products. Golden Bear Cookie Co., Inc., was indebted to the objecting creditor for the merchandise the latter had furnished on credit. On February 27, 1940 Kitzinger had given to the objecting creditor his guaranty up to $10,000 covering its account against Golden Bear Cookie Co., Inc. Golden Bear Cookie Co., Inc., wished to have its business with the objecting creditor continued and Kitzinger was asked by it to furnish a personal statement of his finances which he did furnish on May 1, 1941 on a printed blank of Golden Bear Cookie Co., Inc., in the following form:

Statement GOLDEN BEAR COOKIE CO., INC., 37-32 22nd Street Long Island City, N.Y. ...19 M. S. Kitzinger Terms: ...

5/1/41

Trust Fund 43,998

Liabilities app. 7,100

Assets 36,898

The referee reached the conclusion that the foregoing statement was false upon the theory that it "was in effect a representation that bankrupt was entitled to the principal of a trust fund in the sum of $43,998.00 and owed debts in the amount of $7,100.00, leaving him with a net worth of $36,989.00", and that he "failed to disclose to the representatives of Geo V. Clark Co., Inc. to whom he gave the statement that he had only a life interest in the said trust fund of $36,898.00." This seems to us a view that the record and indeed the general circumstances do not warrant. We regard the statement as showing on its face that the fund was not absolutely Kitzinger's but only one in which he had some beneficial interest. It might mean that he had no more than a life interest in the fund or it might mean that a contingent or vested interest in the principal would sometime come into his possession. He in fact became entitled to a distribution of capital on May 5, 1941 from the trust fund created by his father's will when he became thirty-five years of age but only to the extent of $8,000 or $9,000, a distribution which he used pro tanto to pay the indebtedness he had listed in the financial statement. He had already told Hirschland, the secretary and treasurer of the objecting creditor, that "he was waiting for his May accounting from the Manufacturers Trust Co., he was going to receive a portion of a trust fund from the Manufacturers Trust, a portion of the principal, which he would then use to reduce our account." Hirschland also said in respect to the principal or income of the trust fund mentioned in the financial statement: "That was the principal of the trust fund and according to my understanding from previous conversations, Mr. Kitzinger told me that various portions of the trust fund were payable to him at different birthdays, twenty-fifth, thirtieth, thirty-fifth, something like that, and that the principal of the trust fund would be paid out to him on those birthdays, that various portions of the principal would be paid out. I don't know whether Mr. Kitzinger ever made the statement that the entire amount would be paid out, I can't recall that definitely, but I do know that large substantial payments from the trust fund were to be made at different birthdays."

Steeves, the president of the objecting creditor, testified among other things as follows:

"Q. You notice on the Exhibit the words 'trust fund' appear? A. Yes.

"Q. You know those funds did not belong to Mr. Kitzinger? A. No, I didn't know they did not ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.