Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

MATTER NOAH'S ARK v. FRED W. GEIB (05/22/68)

SUPREME COURT OF NEW YORK, MONROE COUNTY 1968.NY.41786 <http://www.versuslaw.com>; 290 N.Y.S.2d 453; 56 Misc. 2d 800 May 22, 1968 IN THE MATTER OF NOAH'S ARK, DIVISION OF ECKMAR CORP., PETITIONER,v.FRED W. GEIB, RESPONDENT Wiser, Shaw, Freeman, Van Graafeiland, Harter & Secrest (John F. Mahon of counsel), for petitioner. Harris, Beach, Wilcox, Dale & Linowitz (Kreag Donovan of counsel), for respondent. Marshall E. Livingston, J. Author: Livingston


Marshall E. Livingston, J.

Author: Livingston

 This proceeding is brought pursuant to section 745 of article 7 of the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law to recover possession of real property by the tenant petitioner. Respondent concedes that the tenant was forcibly evicted from the premises following a fire which occurred February 5, 1968.

The original tenant, Noah's Ark Auto Accessories, Inc. and its assignee, Phillips-Eckhardt Electronics Corporation, now known as Noah's Ark, Division of Eckmar Corp., will be referred to at all times as Noah's Ark, and the original landlord, Bull's Head Plaza, Inc. and its assignee, Fred W. Geib, will be referred to hereafter as Geib.

A general background of the occurrences leading up to the fire of February 5, 1968 should be set forth as a prologue to the events upon which this proceeding is based.

Since 1959 and until the fire of February 5, 1968, Noah's Ark had been a tenant of spaces designated as stores 9, 10, 11 and the second floor over store 9 in one of the buildings at the Bull's Head Plaza, sharing a building with a coin laundromat to the north and a shoe store (Thom McAn) and a drug store (Daw's) to the south. Noah's Ark occupied approximately 7,250 square feet of floor space of which approximately 6,700 square feet was on the first floor. The building itself is of steel column and girder construction covered by a concrete roof, insulation and roofing material. The sidewalls were partitioned with two-by-four studding faced with plasterboard. The store front of about 60 feet was constructed of glass windows and doors set in aluminum frames. Across the rear of the sales area, about 75 feet from the front, was a partition behind which were two storerooms separated longitudinally by a hall and a stairway to a second story storeroom. A garage also was at the rear of the store, and the rear wall of the building was of cinder block construction.

Noah's Ark leased the premises from Geib for a term of five years, commencing May 1, 1959. The lease provided for two extensions of five years each on the same terms, at the tenant's option, at an agreed guaranteed minimum rental of $9,600 per year, or an annual rental equal to 4% of the tenant's annual gross sales, whichever was larger.

Noah's Ark had apparently given notice to Geib, exercising its option for the first five-year renewal of the lease.

On June 21, 1966, at a time when Noah's Ark was in arrears in rental payments for at least three months, it filed a petition in bankruptcy in United States Bankruptcy Court, Western District of New York, seeking relief under chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Act. Phillips-Eckhardt Electronics Corporation thereafter purchased the assets of Noah's Ark, including its leasehold rights, and this arrangement was approved by the Bankruptcy Court on August 19, 1966. On August 30, 1966 the sale and assignment of leases was consummated by an order of said court.

In September of 1966, after the consummated assignment, Geib demanded the removal of the tenant from the premises, by notice. The matter was brought before the Bankruptcy Court because the termination notice related to the insolvency clause under the lease. By stipulation of both parties, the court entered an order declaring the termination notice void and of no effect.

About September 28, 1966 a proceeding was started by Geib in Monroe County Court against Noah's Ark and Phillips-Eckhardt to recover possession of his real property. It appears that even before that proceeding was started, Peter R. Geib, respondent's son and conceded general agent, insisted, on August 30 and again on September 8, 1966, that the tenant quit the premises. On September 19, 1966, November 9, 1966 and January 9, 1967, notices to terminate the lease were also sent to Noah's Ark by or in behalf of Geib. The petition in County Court was subsequently discontinued. It is apparent that since the early summer of 1966, when Noah's Ark was behind in its rent, Geib has tried unsuccessfully to terminate the lease.

On February 5, 1968, a fire occurred in the premises leased by Noah's Ark, also damaging the Thom McAn shoe store on the south and a coin laundry on the north side of Noah's Ark. The next day Noah's Ark notified Geib in writing of the fire, pursuant to paragraph seventh of the lease, which provides as follows:

"Seventh. That the Tenant shall, in case of fire, give immediate notice thereof to the Landlord who shall thereupon cause the damage to be repaired forthwith; but if the premises be so damaged that the Landlord shall decide to rebuild, the term shall cease and the accrued rent be paid up to the time of the fire."

On February 13, 1968 Geib's attorneys (Exhibit 4), in his behalf, notified Noah's Ark of his decision to rebuild and that the lease was thereby terminated. On March 15, 1968 Geib, by registered mail, again notified Noah's Ark (Exhibit 3) of his decision to rebuild and terminate the lease in accordance with the second clause of the above-quoted paragraph seventh.

On March 18, 1968 Noah's Ark brought this proceeding by petition, in conformance with article 7 of the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law, to recover possession of the real property from which it had ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.