Concur -- Stevens, J. P., Steuer, Tilzer, McGivern and Rabin, JJ.
These are consolidated proceedings to reduce the real estate tax assessments for the years 1961-62 through 1964-65, on premises 25 Sutton Place South, a new, luxury-type co-operative apartment house known as Cannon Point North. The petitioner failed in its burden of establishing by clear and convincing proof that the assessments were erroneous, while the respondent-appellant on the other hand affirmatively demonstrated the correctness of the valuations fixed by the assessors. A ground lease rental of $137,500 net per annum made in 1957, capitalized at the 5% rate fixed in the lease, established a land valuation of $2,750,000, or 147% of the final land assessment of $1,875,000. The actual cost of construction of the 19-story and penthouse building completed in 1960 was $9,764,460, or 141% of the final building assessment of $6,925,000. The sales price of the property (the leasehold interest and the building) to the petitioner in 1959 was $14,450,000, or 164% of its final assessment of $8,800,000. The respondent-appellant's 36 sales, the only sales in the record, occurred between 1953 and 1963 at prices averaging 224% of the assessed valuations. These transactions, too, served to show the consistent upward trend in the area. In the face of this proof, as well as the credible expert testimony of the appellant's appraiser, the court was unwarranted in reducing the combined assessments by $2,350,000, or 7%.
Final order appealed from entered on or about May 11, 1965, unanimously reversed, on the law and the facts, the petitions dismissed and the assessments reinstated, with $50 costs and disbursements to the appellant.