Buy This Entire Record For
MARQUA PITTS v. TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY ET AL. (03/21/69)
SUPREME COURT OF NEW YORK, SPECIAL TERM, ERIE COUNTY
1969.NY.40891 <http://www.versuslaw.com>; 298 N.Y.S.2d 209; 59 Misc. 2d 142
March 21, 1969
MARQUA PITTS, PLAINTIFF,v.TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY ET AL., DEFENDANTS
John M. Garrity for plaintiff.
Sheldon Hurwitz for Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, defendant.
Adams, Brown, Starrett & Maloney for Travelers Insurance Company, defendant.
Michael Catalano, J.
Plaintiff seeks a declaratory judgment determining whether on the date of an automobile accident, May 24, 1967, when defendant, Willie Ross, Sr. (Ross Sr.) owned a 1961 Oldsmobile which was being operated by Willie Ross, Jr. (Ross Jr.) so as to collide with an automobile operated and owned by plaintiff, a policy of insurance issued by defendant, Travelers Insurance Company (Travelers), to Ross Sr. was in effect or was validly cancelled.
Travelers and defendant, Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, (Liberty) are authorized insurance carriers.
October 21, 1966, Travelers issued public liability insurance policy, No. PQMV-6974757, effective October 20, 1966 to October 20, 1967, insuring Ross Sr's. Oldsmobile. The same date, Ross Sr. entered into a premium finance agreement with the Manufacturers & Traders Trust Company (M & T) of Buffalo, New York for installment payment of said insurance. Ross Sr. operated his Oldsmobile until October 24, 1967 when he surrendered his registration certificate and plates.
February 9, 1967, Travelers mailed to Ross Sr. a notice of cancellation of said insurance, effective February 21, 1967, for nonpayment of premiums, but Travelers failed to file such a notice in the office of the Commissioner of Motor Vehicles.
April 28, 1967, defendant, Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, issued public liability insurance policy No. AN1-282-41125, effective April 28, 1967 to April 28, 1968, to plaintiff, which policy contained the New York State Uninsured Motorist Endorsement.
May 24, 1967, plaintiff operated his automobile in Buffalo, New York, colliding with said Oldsmobile operated by Ross Jr., resulting in personal injuries and property damage to plaintiff. That same date, Ross Sr. notified Travelers of this accident.
August 23, 1967, plaintiff notified Liberty of said accident.
Liberty disclaims liability to plaintiff because said Oldsmobile owned by Ross Sr. was insured by Travelers when the accident occurred; Travelers disclaims because its policy had been allegedly canceled before then.
December 2, 1967, plaintiff started an action in Supreme Court against Ross Sr. and Ross Jr.
July 24, 1968, plaintiff demanded arbitration with Liberty, pursuant to its said policy.
August 2, 1968, Liberty started an action in Supreme Court to stay plaintiff's arbitration because Ross Sr. was ...