NML Capital, Ltd. ("NML") in these actions owns defaulted bonds issued by defendant, the Republic of Argentina ("Republic"). NML has been awarded five final judgments against the Republic for a total of about $1.6 billion. On February 7, 2011, NML applied for, and the court signed, an ex parte order of attachment directed to assets of the Republic held at Honeywell International, Inc. in the name of Empresa Argentina de Soluciones Satelitales, S.A. ("ARSAT"). NML now moves to confirm the order of attachment, and non-party ARSAT and the Republic ("Defendants") cross-move to vacate the order of attachment. AR-SAT also cross-moves to recover damages for wrongful attachment.
NML's motion to confirm the order of attachment is denied. The cross-motion of AR-SAT and the Republic is granted, and the February 7, 2011 order of attachment is vacated. The court denies AR-SAT's cross-motion for damages.
NML has eleven actions in this court pertaining to the Republic's bond default in 2001. NML has been awarded five final judgments against the Republic for a total of about $1.6 billion. NML has an additional six causes of action pending before the court for money judgments in favor of NML and against the Republic for a total of about $908 million.
On February 7, 2011, the court ordered an ex parte attachment of certain property of AR-SAT in the possession of Honeywell. The attachment order purported to reach:
Any property in the United States . . . which could be assigned or transferred as provided in N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 5201, including but not limited to Reaction Wheel Assemblies, Miniature Inertial Measurement Units, contractual rights, cash, gold, special drawing rights, deposits, real property, instruments, securities, security entitlements, security accounts, equity interests, and claims, and interests of any kind in the foregoing, directly or indirectly held or maintained in the name of, in a trust held by, or for the use or benefit of AR-SAT or Argentina, and any debt due or to become due to AR-SAT or Argentina from [Honeywell].
On February 8 and 9, 2011, NML levied the order of attachment, and on February 11, the U.S. Marshals Service levied the order of attachment. In its garnishee statement of February 14, 2011, Honeywell stated that it "does not have in its possession or custody any assets or property that are located within the State of New York in which the [Republic] has any interest, either on its own behalf or in the name of [AR-SAT]." However, Honeywell reported holding six items that are the property of AR-SAT located in other states than New York: two "MIMU Inertial Reference Units" and four "HR 12-25RWAs (Reaction Wheel Assembly)." These assets have a combined value of $2,424,600.
Plaintiffs moved to confirm the order of attachment, and the Republic and AR-SAT cross-moved to vacate the order of attachment. AR-SAT also cross-moved to recover damages for wrongful attachment.
The parties submitted several declarations setting forth facts relevant to this dispute. Although they dispute the nature of the Republic's interest in these assets, they generally agree about many of the basic facts. Therefore, except where otherwise indicated, the facts set forth below are undisputed.
AR-SAT is a corporation created by the Argentine Congress on April 5, 2006 pursuant to the Argentine Satellite Solutions Company Act No. 26,092. AR-SAT was created to promote the design, development, construction, launching, and/or commissioning of geostationary telecommunication satellites in the coordinates and frequency bands provided by the International Telecommunications Unit ("I.T.U."). The I.T.U. had granted the Republic the use of the orbital position of 81 Degrees West and its associated frequency bands. Failure to utilize the orbital slot could cause the Republic to forfeit it. Thus, the Republic created AR-SAT and granted it the right to use the 81 Degrees West orbital slot in exchange for payment of .5% of AR-SAT's gross revenues. By Legislative Decree No. 626/2007, the Republic also transferred the 72 Degrees West orbital position to AR-SAT. AR-SAT may not assign or transfer the user permit without authorization from the Republic.
AR-SAT provides satellite capacity across South America, which is used to provide services for corporate networks, government networks, rural telephone services, mobile phone networks, trunking for long distance carriers, audio and video broadcasts, direct TV broadcasts, digital television, internet, video and audio services. Satellite customers pay AR-SAT a fee for that use. In addition to contracts within Argentina, AR-SAT has contracts within other countries in South America to provide satellite ...