Searching over 5,500,000 cases.

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Ramirez v. Ellahi

United States District Court, S.D. New York

April 21, 2014



J. PAUL OETKEN, District Judge.

Plaintiff Paul Anthony Ramirez brings this action for negligence against Defendant Zeeshan Ellahi based upon an alleged motor vehicle-pedestrian accident. Trial is scheduled for June 2, 2014. Ellahi has moved to bifurcate the liability and damages phases pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 42(b). For the reasons stated below, his motion is denied.

I. Background

A. Factual Background

The following facts are drawn from Ramirez and Ellahi's depositions. (Dkt. No. 19, Exs. E & F ("Def. Tr."); Dkt. No. 22, Ex. A.)

On October 7, 2012, sometime around midnight, Ramirez and his friend Steven Chen entered Ellahi's taxi cab after a Jay-Z concert at Barclays Center in Brooklyn, New York. Ramirez and Chen instructed Ellahi that there would be two stops-Chen's residence in Dumbo, followed by Ramirez's girlfriend's residence in the Bronx. Ramirez was seated behind Ellahi and Chen was seated in the rear passenger-side seat. Ramirez and Chen had no conversations with Ellahi until they arrived at Chen's home and Ellahi asked whether they would be paying for the first stop or paying the full fare at the end. Chen paid for the first stop and exited the cab, and Ellahi restarted the meter. Ramirez then explained to Ellahi his next destination and his opinion about the best route. The parties dispute what happened once the cab entered the Bronx.

1. Ramirez's Version of Events

The following is Ramirez's version of the subsequent events. Several blocks after they reached the Bronx, Ellahi told Ramirez that he needed to pay the outstanding fare of approximately $40 immediately because there was a problem with the meter and he needed to restart the vehicle to restart the meter. Ramirez asked Ellahi why this was necessary and Ellahi was unable to explain, so Ramirez told him that he would not pay any amount until they reached his destination, which was still some 60 blocks away. Ellahi then threatened to take Ramirez back to Brooklyn and made a U-turn at 140th Street and Grand Concourse. When the car stopped momentarily, Ramirez opened the rear driver-side door and said he was getting out and calling the cops. When he opened the door-his feet still in the vehicle-Ellahi accelerated and stopped three times. The third time, Ramirez was thrown from the vehicle. When he hit the concrete, he heard a snap, which was later revealed to be a fracture in his right ankle. After some time, he stood up and felt immense pain in his right leg. He tried to make his way to the sidewalk, hobbling, as Ellahi screamed from the vehicle that the police were on their way.

Within several minutes, five police officers arrived in two vehicles. They approached Ramirez and he gave them his ID and told them what happened. He also asked them to help him get medical attention; they offered to take him to Lincoln Medical Center but he declined because he did not have medical insurance. Ramirez had $24 in cash and a debit and credit card. When the officers attempted to settle the dispute by requiring Ramirez to pay the fare, he said he did not have any money on his debit card. The officers took the $24 and asked Ellahi if it was acceptable. Ellahi responded that it was and left, as did the police. Ramirez then called his girlfriend and she came to pick him up.

2. Ellahi's Version of Events

The following is Ellahi's version of events. Shortly after they reached the Bronx, Ellahi stopped at a traffic light. There was no problem with his meter and he did not prematurely demand payment. Ramirez suddenly opened the door and ran away. As Ramirez opened the door, Ellahi shouted that he needed to pay. Ellahi yelled to the fleeing Ramirez that he would call the police; he then called them and said that he had a passenger who was attempting to run away without paying his fare. Ramirez ran to another cab, but when he tried to get in it started to move and he fell. Ramirez quickly got back up and ran to try and catch other cabs that were driving by.

The police did not show up for several minutes. When Ramirez got into another cab, Ellahi told the driver not to take Ramirez because he did not pay his fare and the police were on their way. The driver of that vehicle was trying to leave but could not because Ellahi had stopped his car in front of him. Ramirez then got out of that vehicle and it drove off. The police showed up at about the same time. Ellahi told the police what had happened and an officer-an unidentified Asian man-asked Ramirez for money and Ramirez gave him a credit or debit card. The officer or Ellahi swiped the card and it was declined. The officer asked Ramirez if he had any other way of paying, and Ramirez searched his pockets and found $21. The officer took that money and gave it to Ellahi, who accepted it and drove away. The police drove away at the same time and Ellahi did not see what happened to Ramirez.

B. Procedural Background

Ramirez filed a complaint in New York State Supreme Court, Bronx County, on November 2, 2012. (Dkt. No. 1 ("Removal") ΒΆ 1.) Ellahi removed the action to federal court on November 30 and answered on December 5, 2012. ( Id.; Dkt. No. 2.) Following discovery, trial was scheduled for April 7, 2014 and thereafter adjourned to ...

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.